Discussion of The Dealthy Hallows

I've been thinking about where the true locket could be. Many people say in Number 12 Grimmauld Place. That could very well be but I can't help but wonder about the scene in the cave in The Half Blood Prince. When Harry tried to use the summoning charm on the locket the body jumped out of the water. After looking at the locket a note said that "R.A.B." stole the locket. I can't help but wonder why only one body came out of the water when Harry tried to summon the locket. Maybe R.A.B (Regalus Black) never made it out of the cave and was dragged down into the water by the other bodies in the water with the locket. That would explain why only one body broke the surface. When Harry tried to summon the locket he not only brought the locket up but the body it was on or the body that was holding it. That is my theory of where the locket is and I've been wanting to get it out and get some feedback. It's a little bit of a stretch but i think it could be possible. Tell me what you think and any other ideas or theories you might have.

Please keep a spoiler warning in the titles of posts when the discussion may include spoilers/speculations.

-Andy

Okay, I'll bite. If it isn't at Grimmauld Place, then it was in Kreatur's stash of family heirlooms, and he took it to Hogwarts. Since Dumbledore died, he can move between paintings of himself, and I'm going to guess there's at least one painting in the place the house elves live (because they really liked Dumbledore.) Maybe D will discover it and tell Harry where it is.

We will know in a couple of weeks.

I just assumed that RAB destroyed it so Harry wouldn't have to worry about it. Of course, I could be wrong. Didn't even think about the fact that it could still be out there. But both these theories make sense.

Mark

I'm extremely excited. Tonight the book comes out at midnight and all of our questions will be answered. Time to see if my prediction was correct.

so how are people doing on hits with reviews of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows?

Probably too soon to really judge. I posted yesterday, and only have one outside hit this morning.

...as I expected, but still decent. I think I'm up around 90 and I was the second person to post a review.

But, then again, I'm not a TR so I can't imagine mine getting fantastic hits in Books like some others will.

Jen

I took the time and trouble to make sure that my Harry Potter book review was under the list of reviews where a side photo of the book actually LINKED to said Link.

Well today, I went to the Books page, and saw at the Top Right of the page, the Harry Potter Book as being the number one most popular book

IS IT LINKED TO ALL OUR $x*$% REVIEWS????

No, it is linked to a sole somewhat helpful review.

I really try not to get mad at epinions, I like it here, I really do, but this is ridiculous! Why don't they have some consistency to the darn links! You come to Epinions to read book reviews, and say, oh theres the Harry Potter book right there, I'll click on the picture and instead of everyones review, they get one SH review, and go off to look on Amazon.

shop who normally doesn't get ticked off

Why don't they dig deep and shell out $8/hr for some kid off the street to surf the site and point this stuff out for them. It sometimes doesn't seem like they ever look at the site for themselves.

-Andy

...
There are now two 'Somewhat Helpful' reviews available at that link.



...tom...
.