Epinions.com 
Join Epinions | Help | Sign In   
Home > Message Boards > Books > General Books > 100 books every child should read...

100 books every child should read...
Posts on this Topic   Search in General Books   
Showing 1-11 of 11 posts      
Hide member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
   
sleeper54 Original Post: Jan 23 '08,  5:00 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 436
Member since: Feb 24 '01
Post: 169752
100 books every child should read...

...
100 books every child should read

Just scanned through it (not reading through) but found many expected and some new ones.


Interesting.



...tom...
.

   
befus Posted: Jan 24 '08,  5:53 am           Reply
Reviews written: 588
Member since: May 21 '03
Post: 169794
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Great link, Tom! Thank you for posting this!

I read the introductory essay (nicely done) and then scanned the list. You're right, some I expected and some I found surprising. The list is heavily weighted toward the English, but considering the source, that's to be expected. (I think the Brits write most of the best children's literature anyway. Grin.)

Any glaring omissions for you? I'm still thinking on that one myself...

   
carstairs38 Posted: Jan 24 '08,  10:02 am           Reply
Reviews written: 949
Member since: Oct 03 '05
Post: 169822
RE: 100 books every child should read...

I couldn't believe the number of those I had never heard of.

Mark

   
befus Posted: Jan 24 '08,  10:38 am           Reply
Reviews written: 588
Member since: May 21 '03
Post: 169830
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Yes, there were definitely some of those. And then there were some where I knew the author, but not necessarily that title. I guess a list like that has to be a bit subjective...books the compiler loved as a child and loved reading to his children, etc.

It strikes me that poetry wasn't very well represented. Did I blink and miss Robert Louis Stevenson? Either his Child's Garden of Verses (for poetry) or his Treasure Island (for adventure) seem like good candidates. Maybe they're there...I'll have to check the list again!

It also struck me as odd that the compiler listed the entire Narnia series and the entire Pullman series (strange bedfellows indeed, and I don't agree that every child "should" read Pullman) but only included book 3 from Rowling. I agree Azkaban is a terrific book, but part of its greatness it where it stands in the middle of the series...you need the books before it and after it!

Loved seeing Noel Streatfeld's *Ballet Shoes* -- very good choice there, but not one you always see.

I really need to go back and look at that list...now I'm thinking of all sorts of books I think should be on there, but can't remember if they were! :-)

   
scmrak Posted: Jan 24 '08,  11:40 am (Updated: Jan 24 '08,  6:14 pm)           Reply
Reviews written: 1209
Member since: Sep 27 '00
Post: 169842
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Quote: carstairs38
I couldn't believe the number of those I had never heard of.
Actually, I couldn't believe the number of them that I had read... the vast majority from the nineteenth century or the first half of the twentieth (considering when I was a child, I suppose that makes sense).

Yes - LeGuinn's Wizard of Earthsea...

but where's the Lorax?
   
carstairs38 Posted: Jan 25 '08,  10:06 am           Reply
Reviews written: 949
Member since: Oct 03 '05
Post: 169912
RE: 100 books every child should read...

I know I saw Treasure Island on the list, and I would have sworn The Lorax was there, too. I know my favorite Seuss tale didn't make it. How the Grinch Stole Christmas was read year round when I was a kid.

Mark

   
scmrak Posted: Jan 25 '08,  1:00 pm (Updated: Jan 25 '08,  1:01 pm)           Reply
Reviews written: 1209
Member since: Sep 27 '00
Post: 169946
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Quote: carstairs38
I know I saw Treasure Island on the list, and I would have sworn The Lorax was there, too. I know my favorite Seuss tale didn't make it. How the Grinch Stole Christmas was read year round when I was a kid.
Yesh, the site's so treacly slow (in hounour of its BriutFlauvour) right now I can't get to the second page... but I agree that Treasure Island was in there, though not particularly prominently placed. The only Seuss books I saw were Yertle the Turtle and Cat in the Hat. Could be wrong. It's been known to happen...

-30-
r
ex
   
pestyside Posted: Jan 25 '08,  8:45 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 799
Member since: Jul 19 '05
Post: 170025
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Quote: carstairs38
I couldn't believe the number of those I had never heard of.

Mark


And the few I've actually read. I've a few additions to recommend.

Patsy
   
pestyside Posted: Jan 25 '08,  8:47 pm           Reply
Reviews written: 799
Member since: Jul 19 '05
Post: 170026
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Staring at this it seems like the Brits have written the most, but I'm gearing up to create my own top 100. I wonder how far that will go?
Patsy

   
sleeper54 Posted: Jan 26 '08,  11:03 am           Reply
Reviews written: 436
Member since: Feb 24 '01
Post: 170078
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Quote: pestyside
--snip--

I wonder how far that will go?
Patsy

Uhmmm . . .to one hundred..??



...tom...
' who suspects that is a trick question . . ..'
.
   
befus Posted: Jan 29 '08,  9:49 am           Reply
Reviews written: 588
Member since: May 21 '03
Post: 170385
RE: 100 books every child should read...

Patsy, looking forward to seeing your list! I hope you post it in the writer's corner when it's done!

Hide member images Print     Start a new topic     Post a Reply
Showing 1-11 of 11 posts      
Return to top

Help | Member Center | Message Boards | Site Rules | User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Site Index | Topic Index  
About Epinions | Careers | Contact Epinions | Advertising  

Epinions | Shopping.com | Rent.com | Free Classifieds

Shopping.com Network © 1999-2008 Shopping.com, Inc. Trademark Notice

Epinions.com periodically updates pricing and product information from third-party sources,
so some information may be slightly out-of-date. You should confirm all information before relying on it.